Reuters Falsely Links Jerusalem Embassy, Two-State Solution
The Jerusalem office park which houses Guatemala’s embassy
Multiple recent Reuters articles incorrectly report that moving the Brazilian embassy from Tel Aviv to Jerusalem is a dramatic move away from the two-state solution. For instance, a Dec. 30 article, “Brazil moving its embassy to Jerusalem matter of ‘when, not if’: Netanyahu,” (Dec. 30) reported about the possible Brazilian move:
Such a move by Bolsonaro would be a sharp shift in Brazilian foreign policy, which has traditionally backed a two-stated solution to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.
That piece appeared in Arabic as well.
A Dec. 31 article, “Bolsonaro takes office in Brazil, says nation ‘liberated from socialism,” took an even more extreme line, saying a Jerusalem embassy move would be a “break” from the two-state solution:
As a clear sign of that diplomatic shift, Bolsonaro plans to move the Brazilian embassy in Israel from Tel Aviv to Jerusalem, breaking with Brazil’s traditional support for a two-state solution to the Palestinian issue.
In fact, as is apparent from the cases of the American and Guatemalan embassies, relocation to Jerusalem is not a shift away from a two-state solution.
Daniel Shapiro, who served as Ambassador to Israel under President Obama, wrote in The Washington Post:
[N]othing about our embassy’s location there would prevent the emergence of a shared city with two capitals as part of a two-state solution. Perhaps inadvertently, President Trump’s decision has opened the door for much more frank discussion about an eventual Palestinian capital, and U.S. Embassy to Palestine, in East Jerusalem.
He explained:
West Jerusalem has served as Israel’s capital since the founding of the state, and no plausible two-state map would change that. Our embassy’s presence in the city reinforces the legitimacy of historic Jewish ties to the city, which are too often denied by Palestinians.
Indeed, as Reuters itself just reported, U.S. Secretary of State Mike Pompeo recently expressed openness to a two-state solution (“Pompeo says US open to ‘two-party solution“):
U.S. Secretary of State Mike Pompeo suggested on Monday he was open to a two-state solution to the Israeli-Palestinian dispute, saying a “two-party solution” was likely in his first extensive comments on peace efforts since taking the job last week.
In addition, as Reuters reported Sept. 26: “Trump says he wants two-state solution for Middle East conflict.”
These lines are being written dozens of meters away from Guatemala’s embassy in southern Jerusalem. There is no evidence that Guatemala does not support a two-state solution.
Thus, there is no linkage between the location of a country’s embassy in Jerusalem and its policy vis-à-vis a two-state solution. The location of foreign embassies in Jerusalem does not preclude the future establishment of a Palestine state, even one whose capital lies in part of the holy city of Jerusalem.
More from SNAPSHOTS
Where’s the Coverage? Palestinians Attack Palestinian Security Forces
November 29, 2016
A group of Palestinians shot at and bombed Palestinian Authority (PA) security forces in a little reported incident on Nov. 17, 2016. According to Palestinian Ma’an News Agency, “a group of Palestinian youth…shot live fire [...]
BREAKING: InterVarsity Press in United States to Cease Publication of Stephen Sizer’s Books
November 21, 2016
Earlier this week, Harry's Place (hurryupharry.org) reported that IVP, an Evangelical publishing house announced that it would no longer publish books written by the controversial anti-Zionist Rev. Dr. Stephen Sizer, an Anglican priest from England. [...]
Analyst: The U.S. Should Cut Aid to Lebanese Armed Forces
November 21, 2016
The U.S. Congress should “immediately defund the Lebanese Armed Forces,” a recent Weekly Standard article argues (“The Lebanese Army Is Misusing U.S. Aid,” Nov. 14, 2016). In his commentary, Lee Smith, a senior editor at [...]
Where’s the Coverage? Incitement in Palestinian Textbooks
November 16, 2016
Since the “knife intifada,” as it’s become known, began in the fall of 2015, we’ve been hearing the narrative that says that “Palestinian despair” or “Palestinian frustration” over Israel’s military administration of the West Bank [...]
International Business Times Pulls a UNESCO on Temple Mount
November 13, 2016
In a headline and accompanying first paragraph, The International Business Times takes a page from UNESCO's book on the Temple Mount, casting Judaism's holiest site as Islamic only. "Israel Wants Jews To Pray at Muslim [...]
German Authorities Investigate Facebook for Allowing Holocaust Denial
November 9, 2016
German officials are investigating four Facebook executives, including the company’s founder Mark Zuckerberg, over allegations that the social media network tolerates hate speech, Holocaust denial and incitement—violating Germany’s national hate speech laws. A report by [...]
PA Official: Honoring Terrorists is Our Culture
November 4, 2016
PA President Mahmoud Abbas A Palestinian Authority (PA) official, Issam Abu Bakr, has defended the authority’s decision to name a school after an arch-terrorist. Palestinian Media Watch (PMW), a non-profit organization that monitors Arab media [...]