A Brooklyn College Professor Weighs in on the Petersen-Overton Controversy
Brooklyn College Professor of Philosophy Emerita Abigail Rosenthal has written a letter to the National Association of Scholars arguing that due process rather than academic freedom is the main issue in the controversial case of Kristofer Petersen-Overton, a 26-year-old pro-Palestinian activist and 2nd year grad student who was hired to teach a course about the Middle East and Arab-Israeli conflict. The Professor writes:
Due process was not followed in the hire. (A second-year student in the PhD program is under-credentialed to teach a graduate course, & his course syllabus, which included a history component, wasn’t cleared with the History Dept.) Due process was also not followed in his firing. I think due process, rather than academic freedom, was the main issue here.
She notes that “it’s probable that the Political Science Dept.’s rush to hire Petersen-Overton was connected to his views” and comments on the one-sided sanctioning of opinion and the hostile atmosphere for Jewish students on campus .
It seems to me that by now the campus has generated a hostile atmosphere for Jewish students & has conveyed the message (via the orientation text, via political theatre on campus, via this now-underscored hire, via the expanded “Israel Apartheid Week”), to students & faculty, that only one political view has official sanction, from the effective faculty & administration.
Read Professor Rosenthal’s letter here.
More from SNAPSHOTS
Updated: Is Yohanna Katanacho Telling the Whole Story About West Bank Travel Restrictions?
July 18, 2016
Rev. Dr. Yohanna Katanacho speaks at the 2012 Christ at the Checkpoint Conference in 2012. (Dexter Van Zile) Note: This article has been updated. Scroll to the bottom to see the update. July 18, 2018 [...]
Christian Group Accuses WCC’s Peace Activists of Violating Israeli Law
July 14, 2016
EAPPI activists in the West Bank. (Dexter Van Zile) A subsidiary of the World Council of Churches (WCC), an umbrella organization that is comprised of more than 300 Protestant and Orthodox churches throughout the world, [...]
AP Headline on Israeli Law Breaks Journalistic Rule
July 12, 2016
On a controversial new Israeli law to increase regulation of Israeli non-profit organizations which receive more than half of their funding from foreign states, an Associated Press headline violates the journalistic imperative to maintain impartiality. [...]
Christian Science Monitor Headline Errs on ‘New Israeli Settlements’
July 7, 2016
July 12 Update: CAMERA Prompts Christian Science Monitor Correction of Erroneous Headline on 'New Israeli Settlements' Whenever Israel approves plans for new housing units in preexisting West Bank settlements, or in established Jewish neighborhoods in [...]
National Post Headline Casts Doubt: Murder of Hallel Ariel Maybe Not Terrorism
July 4, 2016
July 5 Update: National Post Amends the Headline Following CAMERA's communication with several editors yesterday, editors commendably amended the headline. It now appropriately states: "Palestinian fatally stabs Israeli girl, 13, as she sleeps in her [...]
After Mother of Terrorist Says Son “Hero” and “Martyr,” NY Times Mistranslates to Hide Her Words (UPDATED)
June 30, 2016
UPDATE: Following communication with CAMERA staff, the New York Times has corrected its subtitles. They now accurately show the woman using the word "hero" to describe terrorists like her son, and no longer claim she [...]
UPDATED: The PA Blood Libel Repeated by President Abbas was Already Debunked with CAMERA’s Help
June 27, 2016
June 24, 2016Today's New York Times features a forthright and informative article by Diaa Hadid about Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas' blood libel to the EU. She writes:Echoing anti-Semitic claims that led to the mass killings [...]