A Brooklyn College Professor Weighs in on the Petersen-Overton Controversy
Brooklyn College Professor of Philosophy Emerita Abigail Rosenthal has written a letter to the National Association of Scholars arguing that due process rather than academic freedom is the main issue in the controversial case of Kristofer Petersen-Overton, a 26-year-old pro-Palestinian activist and 2nd year grad student who was hired to teach a course about the Middle East and Arab-Israeli conflict. The Professor writes:
Due process was not followed in the hire. (A second-year student in the PhD program is under-credentialed to teach a graduate course, & his course syllabus, which included a history component, wasn’t cleared with the History Dept.) Due process was also not followed in his firing. I think due process, rather than academic freedom, was the main issue here.
She notes that “it’s probable that the Political Science Dept.’s rush to hire Petersen-Overton was connected to his views” and comments on the one-sided sanctioning of opinion and the hostile atmosphere for Jewish students on campus .
It seems to me that by now the campus has generated a hostile atmosphere for Jewish students & has conveyed the message (via the orientation text, via political theatre on campus, via this now-underscored hire, via the expanded “Israel Apartheid Week”), to students & faculty, that only one political view has official sanction, from the effective faculty & administration.
Read Professor Rosenthal’s letter here.
More from SNAPSHOTS
UKMW Prompts Correction to SKY News Claim on US View of Settlements
January 18, 2017
On January 15, 2017, Sky News ran a segment titled ‘Two-state solution under Trump’, focusing on concerns that Israeli settlement construction and the president-elect’s pledge to move the US embassy from Tel Aviv to Jerusalem [...]
If Hamas Assaults a Journalist, Does it Even Make the News?
January 16, 2017
On. Jan. 12, 2017, Hamas, the U.S.-designated terror group that rules the Gaza Strip, assaulted an Agence France-Press (AFP) photographer and detained—at gunpoint—an Associated Press journalist. Western media outlets largely ignored the violence against members [...]
Politico’s Misleading Poll on Israeli-Palestinian Conflict
January 12, 2017
A Dec. 28-29 national tracking poll of American public opinion by Politico asked misleading questions about the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict. The survey by Morning Consult and Politico asked multiple more than 60 questions, the vast majority [...]
Iran Planned Terror Attacks Against German Pro-Israel Advocates
January 12, 2017
Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, the Supreme Ruler of Iran The Islamic Republic of Iran planned to assassinate a German pro-Israel advocate, according to The Jerusalem Post(“Iran planned terror attacks against Israel advocates in Germany,” Jan. 7, [...]
Incomplete Headlines Mislead on Elor Azaria Shooting
January 4, 2017
After an Israeli military court today convicted Israeli soldier Elor Azaria of manslaughter for fatally shooting a wounded Palestinian assailant in Hebron last April, several media outlets published incomplete and misleading headlines, ignoring the fact [...]
NPR Conducts Hostile Interview with Israeli Ambassador Over UN Resolution
December 28, 2016
All Things Considered’s Robert Siegel conducted a hostile interview with Israeli Ambassador Ron Dermer over Israeli criticism of the Obama Administration’s alleged role in the United Nations Security Council Resolution 2334. The resolution has deemed [...]
Reuters Reduces Israeli Ties to West Bank to Biblical Claim Only
December 25, 2016
In an article yesterday ("Israel to re-assess U.N. ties after settlement resolution, says Netanyahu"), Reuters reduces Israel's claim to the West Bank to biblical only. Ignoring Israel's legal claim along with a very long historical [...]