Train Shooting 2.0
When software engineers issue a new version of code, they typically communicate the change to their customers by labeling adding a number such as “2.0” to the original title of the software.
A similar process is at work regarding the coverage of the train shooting that killed one Coptic Christian and left five others wounded on Tuesday Jan. 11, 2011. On the day of the attack, Al Masry Al Youm reported that security officials said gunmen looked for crosses tatooed on the wrists of his victims before shooting them. Other reports stated that the gunman chanted “God is Great” during the attack.
The story however, has changed. Al Masry Al Youm has interviewed Mahmoud Abdul Bassit Hamid who took the gun from the assailant’s hand. The paper reports the following in its Jan. 14 online edition:
Hamid said newspapers (sic) reports that the suspect repeated phrases such as “Allah is great” [Allahu Akbar] were untrue. According to him, the suspect was silent and fired haphazardly during the shooting, which Hamid said lasted less than three minutes.
This story is contradicted by an article by Mary Abdelmassih from the Assyrian International News Agency (AINA), and published in The Pakistan Christian Post on the same day as the Al Masry Al Youm piece.
The piece reports the official line from the Egyptian government (the attacker was “mentally unstable” and that there was no sectarian motive to the attacks) and then provides valuable context about the credibilty of such assertions to its readers.
The Coptic Diocese of Minya said that the perpetrator went up and down the train compartment before shooting at the Copts while chanting Islamic chants.
Dr.Naguib Ghabrial, head of the Egyptian Union of Human Rights Organizations, described the incident as a premeditated “sectarian” attack, aimed at the Copts, since they sat together and sang Christian hymns, and the assailant shouted Allahu Akbar three times before shooting.
Ghabrial criticized the Interior Ministry for downplaying the shooting as usual. “The gunman did not shoot at random, otherwise Muslims would have been wounded as well,” Ghabrial told BBC Arabic TV. “This is one in the series of attacks aimed at Copts, before this there was the Alexandria Massacre.”
“I am sorry that the Ministry hastily issued a statement that the assailant was mentally unstable.” Said Ghabrial. ” Would someone who is mentally unstable be issued with a weapon and ammunition, would he be able to differentiate between Copts and Muslims?” he said. “I am telling the Interior Minister do not under-estimate Coptic intelligence and do not undervalue Coptic blood, for Coptic blood is not cheap.” He called once again for the minister to resign after all these Coptic Massacres.
In its coverage of the attack, the Los Angeles Times, reports the following:
But earlier on Wednesday, AFP quoted a Samalut priest as saying that he was told by victims that the assailant targeted Copts, picking out people near a group of women not wearing headscarves: “The victims told me that after he was certain, he raised his gun and yelled ‘Allahu akbar’ or ‘God is great,'” a priest identified as Morkos said, according to AFP.
One victim told Al Youm Al Sabee, an Egyptian independent news website, that “the offender yelled ‘la ilah illa Allah,’ or “there is no god but Allah'” rather than “Allahu akbar.”
What explains the changing narrative? It’s difficult to say. Maybe initial reports were incorrect. It’s entirely possible given the chaos that probably attended the shooting itself.
Or maybe the Egyptian government is working to mold the story to downplay the sectarian nature of the attack.
In any event, Coptic leaders are convinced the attack was motivated by anti-Christian hostility and that the assailant specifically targeted Christians.
In other words, they won’t be buying the upgrade.
More from SNAPSHOTS
Reuters Falsely Links Jerusalem Embassy, Two-State Solution
January 9, 2019
The Jerusalem office park which houses Guatemala's embassy Multiple recent Reuters articles incorrectly report that moving the Brazilian embassy from Tel Aviv to Jerusalem is a dramatic move away from the two-state solution. For instance, [...]
American Lutheran In Jerusalem Affirms that IDF Soldiers Are “Stormtroopers,” Backtracks
December 19, 2018
Rev. Carrie Ballenger Smith is a pastor at the Church of the Redeemer in Jerusalem. She ministers to the English-speaking congregation that meets at the Lutheran church, which is located in the Old City of [...]
The Washington Post Ignores Antisemitic Attack in Los Angeles
November 29, 2018
The Washington Post has warned about a “rising tide of antisemitism.” But as CAMERA has highlighted, The Post’s coverage of antisemitism has frequently been selective and is often politicized. More recently, the newspaper even ignored [...]
Think Tank: Iran Was Closer to Building a Bomb Than Previously Thought
November 23, 2018
A Nov. 20, 2018 report by a Washington D.C.-based think tank, the Institute for Science and International Security (ISIS) argues that Iran’s illegal nuclear weapons program was “more advanced than Western intelligence agencies and the [...]
AFP Headline Casts Palestinian Assailant as Victim
November 21, 2018
Agence France Presse yesterday published a throwback headline, bringing us back to the period almost two years ago in which media outlets serially produced headlines which depicted Palestinian attackers as the victims. The wire agency's [...]
More Hypocrisy and Anti-Semitism From Linda Sarsour
November 19, 2018
In an earlier CAMERA exposé, we pointed out the self-serving allegiances and disgraceful hypocrisy of Linda Sarsour (of Women's March fame). We demonstrated how she poses as a universal activist who embraces all marginalized people [...]
Small Steps: Improved NY Times Language on Target of Hamas Rockets
November 15, 2018
Earlier this week, we pointed out how a New York Times article about fighting between Israel and Hamas neglected to inform readers that Palestinian rockets were fired indiscriminately toward civilians in Israeli towns and cities. [...]