AFP Falsely Ties Victim to White Phosphorous
There has been no shortage of Palestinian wounded for photo services to document, so it is odd that AFP falsely links an injured boy to claims about white phosphorous. Consider the following photo and caption:
Palestinian Loua Sobeh, 10, is treated for burns at Shifa hospital in Gaza City on January 12, 2009. Palestinian doctor working in Gaza City Dr. Yusef Abu Rish told AFP that at least 55 people were injured early yesterday by white phosphorous shells, banned under international law for use against civilians, but permitted for creating smokescreens. “These people were burned over their bodies in a way that can only be caused by white phosphorous,” said Abu Rish. An Israeli military spokeswoman denied the claims. “There is no use of white phosphorous. Everything we use is according to international law,” she said. AFP Photo/Yasser Aymeh, Jan. 12, 2009
While AFP does not explicitly state that Sobeh was injured by white phosphorous, the gratuitous inclusion of Dr. Abu Rish’s statement strongly implies that he is. And some media outlets got the message. The San Francisco Chronicle and the Daily News (Egypt) for instance, used this photo of Sobeh to illustrate their articles about claims concerning Israeli use of white phosphorous.
Meanwhile, it has become clear that Louai Sobeh, who gave his testimony to B’Tselem, was not injured by white phosphorous. He told B’Tselem he was injured in an attack by combat helicopters and gunfire, and according to the Palestinian Center for Human Rights, he was injured by tank fire. Tellingly, neither organization mentions white phosphorous.
Why, then, given the supposedly high number of casualties due to white phosphorous does AFP resort to falsely linking a victim to the weapon?
Perhaps, because despite the reports on CNN about the “Nasty, Nasty Weapon” which has brought casualties to Shifa Hospital, the Red Cross’ delegation to that hospital did “not come across injuries which could be proved to be from white phosphorus.”
For more on false claims about white phosphorous, see here.
More from SNAPSHOTS
CNN’s Amanpour Condemns “power grab” By Israel’s Prime Minister and Others
April 1, 2020
We’ve said it often, but it’s worth repeating: Anyone interested in reasonably unbiased information about Israel (at least) should avoid the broadcasts of CNN’s Chief International Correspondent and Anchor, Christiane Amanpour. In characterizing responses to [...]
Seattle Media Oblivious To Imam’s Hateful Indoctrination Condemning Jews
January 7, 2020
The Masjid Ar-Rahmah mosque teaching – that Allah transformed Jews into apes and pigs for disobeying him – delivered by Imam (prayer leader) Mohamad Joban – was posted online by mosque personnel. This December 2019 [...]
AP Distorts: Bethlehem ‘Almost Completely Surrounded’
December 10, 2019
Over two years after improving inaccurate language falsely citing Israel's security "barrier surrounding the biblical city" of Bethlehem, the Associated Press once again misrepresents. AP's Joseph Krauss and Mohammad Daraghmeh wrote yesterday ("Palestinians in Bethlehem [...]
Reuters Errs on Administrative Detention For ‘Anti-Israel Activity’
November 5, 2019
The Ofer Prison, near Ramallah (Photo by Tamar Sternthal) A Reuters article today egregiously misrepresents administrative detention, erroneously asserting that it is mainly applied to "Palestinians suspected of anti-Israeli activities," when in fact the Israeli [...]