Star Tribune Caption Slip-up
Powerline blogs about a photo caption error in the Star Tribune, and the response from the reader’s representative:
Today in her weekly column, Parry describes a mysterious error that appeared in the caption for a photo that tends to undermine the usual MSM line on Israel:
John Kingery had doubts about the motives behind a photo caption last Sunday that read “Palestinians ran through the Erez border crossing Saturday, fleeing the Gaza Strip after Hamas’ takeover. Crowds converged on the border checkpoint, but only a small number were allowed through to Egypt.”
The problem, he wrote, was that the Erez border crossing goes to Israel, not Egypt. What’s more, Kingery located the original Associated Press photo and caption, and saw that the caption the AP provided had correctly said “Palestinians run as they try to cross to the Israel side at the Erez Crossing . …”I reached the conclusion it was either incompetence or bias” that prompted the Star Tribune to change the destination of the fleeing Palestinians, Kingery said. He suspected bias against Israel.
“So the writers/editors of the Star Tribune intentionally changed the caption on an AP photo to read to their bias, completely changing the significance of the photo,” Kingery said.
Nan Williams, the copy editor who wrote the errant caption, said it was far less complex: “I was helping out on deadline. We were crunched. It was a stupid mistake.” A correction about the caption is scheduled to run today.
JOHN adds: This really is an interesting one. This is evidently the photo in question; the caption is lengthy and was not quoted in full by Ms. Parry. Note that it mentions Israel three times, and never mentions Egypt:
Palestinians run as they try to cross to the Israel side at the Erez Crossing, in the northern Gaza Strip, Saturday, June 16, 2007. Dozens of Palestinians converged on the Erez crossing with Israel on Saturday, trying to leave the Gaza Strip following Hamas’ takeover. At the same time, hundreds of people looted police positions on the Palestinian side of Erez, and at one point Israeli troops fired in the air to keep the crowd at bay. The looters walked off with furniture and scrap metal. (AP Photo/Hatem Moussa)
The Star Tribune copy editor shortened the caption considerably, which was probably necessary in view of the caption’s length. The main impact of the abridgment was to eliminate all reference to looting or other misbehavior by the Palestinians. As modified by the Star Tribune, the Palestinians are victims: “Crowds converged” but only a “small number were allowed through.” Assuming I’ve identified the right picture, and I couldn’t find any other candidates, the modification of the caption arguably reflects a set of attitudes and assumptions about the Middle East that is broadly typical of the Star Tribune. The substitution of “Egypt” for “Israel,” notwithstanding the three mentions of Israel in the text, is consistent with these attitudes and assumptions. If it occurred inadvertently as a result of haste, it perhaps represents what liberals like to call “unconscious bias.”
More from SNAPSHOTS
Reuters Falsely Links Jerusalem Embassy, Two-State Solution
January 9, 2019
The Jerusalem office park which houses Guatemala's embassy Multiple recent Reuters articles incorrectly report that moving the Brazilian embassy from Tel Aviv to Jerusalem is a dramatic move away from the two-state solution. For instance, [...]
American Lutheran In Jerusalem Affirms that IDF Soldiers Are “Stormtroopers,” Backtracks
December 19, 2018
Rev. Carrie Ballenger Smith is a pastor at the Church of the Redeemer in Jerusalem. She ministers to the English-speaking congregation that meets at the Lutheran church, which is located in the Old City of [...]
The Washington Post Ignores Antisemitic Attack in Los Angeles
November 29, 2018
The Washington Post has warned about a “rising tide of antisemitism.” But as CAMERA has highlighted, The Post’s coverage of antisemitism has frequently been selective and is often politicized. More recently, the newspaper even ignored [...]
Think Tank: Iran Was Closer to Building a Bomb Than Previously Thought
November 23, 2018
A Nov. 20, 2018 report by a Washington D.C.-based think tank, the Institute for Science and International Security (ISIS) argues that Iran’s illegal nuclear weapons program was “more advanced than Western intelligence agencies and the [...]
AFP Headline Casts Palestinian Assailant as Victim
November 21, 2018
Agence France Presse yesterday published a throwback headline, bringing us back to the period almost two years ago in which media outlets serially produced headlines which depicted Palestinian attackers as the victims. The wire agency's [...]
More Hypocrisy and Anti-Semitism From Linda Sarsour
November 19, 2018
In an earlier CAMERA exposé, we pointed out the self-serving allegiances and disgraceful hypocrisy of Linda Sarsour (of Women's March fame). We demonstrated how she poses as a universal activist who embraces all marginalized people [...]
Small Steps: Improved NY Times Language on Target of Hamas Rockets
November 15, 2018
Earlier this week, we pointed out how a New York Times article about fighting between Israel and Hamas neglected to inform readers that Palestinian rockets were fired indiscriminately toward civilians in Israeli towns and cities. [...]