AFP Doctors Swiss Report on Arafat’s Death, Polonium
An AFP news story and photo captions falsely allege that a Swiss report concluded that Yasser Arafat had been fatally poisoned. For instance, there are these photo captions:
A Palestinian woman walks past a mural of late Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat in Gaza City on July 4, 2012. Arafat, who died in 2004, was poisoned by polonium, according to the findings of laboratory research carried out in Switzerland and cited in an Al-Jazeera report on July 3. AFP PHOTO/MAHMUD HAMSMAHMUD HAMS/AFP/GettyImages
A file picture dated November 16, 2003 shows late Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat smiling to reporters outside his office in the West Bank city of Ramallah. Yasser Arafat, who died in 2004, was poisoned by polonium, according to the findings of laboratory research carried out in Switzerland and cited in an Al-Jazeera report on July 3, 2012. AFP PHOTO/JAMAL ARURIJAMAL ARURI/AFP/GettyImages (Emphases added.)
There was also a July 3 AFP article headlined “Arafat poisoned by polonium: Report,” which begins:
Yasser Arafat, who died in 2004, was poisoned by polonium, according to the findings of laboratory research out in Switzerland and cited in an Al-Jazeera report on Tuesday.
But the Swiss report does not conclude that Arafat died of poisoning. Francois Bochud, head of the Institute of Radiation Physics at the University of Lausanne, the research institute which conducted the study, has repeatedly made clear that that conclusion cannot be drawn from his work.
For instance, the very same AFP article reports in the last paragraphs:
To confirm the theory that he was poisoned by polonium it would be necesseary to exhume and analyse Arafat’s remains, Bochud said.
“If (Suha Arafat) really wants to know what happened to her husband (we need) to find a sample — I mean, an exhumation . . . should provide us with a sample that should have a very high quality of polonium if he was poisoned,” he said.
So the diligent minority who bother to read to the end of the article will get an inkling that, contrary to the articles’s headline and first paragraph, the Swiss report did not, in fact, conclude that Arafat had been poisoned.
In addition, the Associated Press reported:
Mr. Bochud stressed that the discovery did not provide proof that Mr. Arafat had been poisoned. That would require further testing.
“What is possible to say is that we have an unexplained level of polonium, so this clearly goes toward the hypothesis of a poisoning, but our results are clearly not a proof of any poisoning,” he said by telephone from Switzerland.
Even Al Jazeera does not say that the Swiss research concluded that Arafat was poisoned.
More from SNAPSHOTS
The Washington Post Cites—Then Removes—A Tweet From an Antisemite
September 27, 2017
A Washington Post report on U.S. comedian Conan O’Brien’s recent trip to Israel initially cited an antisemitic Twitter user. Following contact from CAMERA, The Post removed the offensive tweet from the online article (“How Conan’s [...]
Journalist Harassed by PA in 2014 Now in Facebook Jail
September 27, 2017
Brian Schrauger, editor and publisher of The Jerusalem Journal. (Photo: Dexter Van Zile) Brian Schrauger, editor of a pro-Israel website The Jerusalem Journal, has, along with a number of his friends and supporters, been placed [...]
The Washington Post Pushes ‘Despair’ Excuse for Palestinian Terrorism, Again
September 26, 2017
PA President Mahmoud Abbas A Washington Post report on a Sept. 26, 2017 Palestinian terror attack pushed the narrative that “despair” and “frustration” over the lack of a Palestinian state was a motivating factor in [...]
Vox: Don’t Say “Radical Islamic Terrorism,” But Definitely Say “Jewish Terrorism”
September 14, 2017
On our main site yesterday, we wrote about Vox's false claim that West Bank settlements are dotted with world-class hospitals that Palestinians can't go into. While looking into that, we noticed something else. Across multiple [...]
In New Yorker, Diana Buttu Fabricates About ‘Fauda’
September 13, 2017
Diana Buttu, a lawyer and former legal advisor for the Palestine Liberation Organization who has infamously and repeatedly insisted that Palestinian rockets fired from Gaza "do not carry explosive heads," and has repeatedly and falsely [...]