NY Times’ Unethical Omission
In an article about the gap between Israeli opinion and much of world opinion about Israel’s actions in the Gaza Strip, the New York Times‘ Jerusalem bureau chief Ethan Bronner omits key information which underscores the Israeli position that the Israeli army is acting justly. He reports:
Moshe Halbertal, a left-leaning professor of philosophy at the Hebrew University, helped write the army’s ethics code. He said he knew from personal experience how much laborious discussion went into deciding when it was acceptable to shoot at a legitimate target if civilians were nearby, adding that there had been several events in this war in which he suspected that the wrong decision had been made.
For example, Israel killed a top Hamas ideologue, Nizar Rayyan, during the first week of the war and at the same time killed his four wives and at least nine of his children. Looking back at it, Mr. Halbertal disapproves, assuming that the decision was made consciously, even if Mr. Rayyan purposely hid among his family to protect himself, as it appears he did. Yet almost no one here publicly questioned the decision to drop a bomb on his house and kill civilians; all the sentiment in Israel was how satisfying and just it was to kill a man whose ideology and activity had been so virulent and destructive.
But, as reported by the Independent (and confirmed by the UN’s OCHA),
The family were warned 30 minutes earlier by the Israel Defence Forces that the house would be attacked, but Mr Rayan’s son-in-law, Mahmoud Albaik, said they had refused to leave and that, urged by his son in a telephone call to leave seconds before the attack, he had said: “I want to be a martyr.”
Thus, it wasn’t an Israeli decision to “kill noncombatants,” but a Hamas decision, carried out by Rayan himself, to let his family die. Isn’t the fact that the family was given 30 minutes notice prior to the bombing absolutely essential to any discussion about the morality of IDF actions? Whether or not Halbertal was aware of this critical point, it is Bronner’s obligation to report it. Bronner wasn’t the first to overlook this key information.
More from SNAPSHOTS
Where’s the Coverage? Israel Offered to Help Iranian and Iraqi Earthquake Victims
November 17, 2017
An Israeli offer to assist Iranian and Iraqi earthquake victims was “immediately rebutted” by Baghdad and Tehran—and widely ignored by major U.S. news outlets. As The Times of Israel reported on Nov. 14, 2017, Israeli [...]
Tucker Carlson Allows Max Blumenthal’s Anti-Israel Comments to Slide
November 16, 2017
This past Tuesday, on his Fox News television show Tucker Carlson Tonight, host Tucker Carlson interviewed Max Blumenthal about the Russian government-funded cable network RT and the Trump administration’s attempt to have that station register [...]
Anti-Israel NGO Admits: Palestinian Children Commit Terror for ‘Status’
November 14, 2017
A PFLP operative The program director for Defence for Children International-Palestine (DCI-P), a Palestinian NGO, admitted in an interview that Palestinian minors commit terror attacks to enhance their societal status. The admission contradicts DCI-P’s propaganda, [...]
Palestinian Authority Admits to Supporting BDS—Violating Oslo
October 27, 2017
PA President Mahmoud Abbas A top Palestinian Authority (PA) official has acknowledged that the authority supports the boycott, divestment and sanctions (BDS) movement. BDS unfairly maligns the Jewish state and denies its existence any legitimacy. [...]