« Ha'aretz Headline Fail | Main | Where's the Coverage? Ayatollah Khamenei Tweets "Zionists are Just Like Nazis" »

December 18, 2013

CNN’s Amanpour Smears Israel at Mandela Memorial Service


During coverage of the December 10 memorial service for the former South African president, Nelson Mandela, held in Johannesburg, frequent Israel basher and CNN (Cable News Network) personality, Christiane Amanpour reminiscing about Mandela, drew what she thought was a key lesson from Mandela’s leadership applicable to an intractable conflict of today. Not Syria’s civil war, not Iraq’s civil war nor any number of other bloody internecine conflicts, but to the Palestinian Arab conflict with Israel,

… as one who's covered so much conflict around the world, you can't help but really, really internalize this notion that without the kind of forgiveness that Mandela was able to exhibit, that's not just something nice. It's not just something between, you know, classroom bullies. It is the quintessential element of conflict resolution. It is a political tool. Forgiveness is a political tool to get over what seems to be intractable conflict. I honestly can't help but think right now about Israel and the Palestinians and any number …

At this point, CNN anchor Chris Cuomo interrupted, interjecting what he thought was an important point, “Israel who doesn't have leadership here today.? Amanpour attempting to correct Cuomo, claimed that Israel’s president (Shimon Peres) was present but not Prime Minister Netanyahu (but Amanpour erred about Peres since Israel was represented by the speaker of the Knesset [parliament] Yuli Edelstein leading a delegation of five ministers. According to the Jerusalem Post, Netanyahu cited the high security cost of the journey and Peres was sick). “And what does that mean, by the way?,? asked Cuomo. Amanpour didn’t pass up an opportunity to pontificate, falsely likening Israel to apartheid South Africa:

Well, the president is the head of state, and he's come. But nonetheless, Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu is under so much, you know, pressure these days and probably feels to a great extent that his country is isolated in the same way that apartheid South Africa was isolated.

But this is how you get over those intractable conflicts, by understanding the story of the other, by having a political process of resolution that is not just about domination or zero-sum game. Mandela knew there was no Africa for the blacks if it meant Africa without the whites. It was not possible.

It is hard to be more superficial. If the Arabs in general and Palestinian Arabs in particular had been interested in "getting over this intractable conflict" with Israel, the Israel-Egyptian and Israeli-Jordanian peace treaties would have grown from just semi-secret military-to-military cooperation to the anticipated economic, cultural and social exchanges. But these the Egyptian and Jordanian public largely rejected. As for Palestinian leadership, it violated most provisions of the Oslo accords, including the anti-incitement and anti-terrorism clauses, from the beginning. Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's calls for a negotiated two-state solution have been met by a Palestinian Authority leadership that rejects Amanpour's "Mandelaism" about "understanding the story of the other;" it adamantly refuses to recognize Israel as the Jewish state. Her unfounded and tendentious speculation that Netanyahu "probably feels his country is isolated the same way apartheid South Africa was isolated" pushes the "apartheid Israel" canard while ignoring that it has been Palestinian leaders who've insisted on "not a single Jew" in any new "Palestine."

So, Amanpour is up to her old and obvious tricks smearing Israel and Jews just as she infamously did in a 2009 CNN special, “Generation Islam.? CAMERA showed that report as manipulative, falsely implying that the villains were not the Islamists who rule Gaza, teaching hatred of Christians and Jews, and attacking Israeli civilians with suicide bombers and thousands of rockets. Instead, for Amanpour, the aggressors were the Jews of Israel, for supposedly oppressing the Palestinian Arabs. Meanwhile she did not mention the hate indoctrination Hamas specializes in.

So, Amanpour remains Amanpour, a real-life cable television version of the film farce "Anchorman 2's" Ron Burgundy character. However, she continues ponderous and misleading rather than the fictional Burgundy's fluff and slapstick. Perhaps Amanpour is destined never to understand the news about Israel and Jews she claims to report.

Posted by MK at December 18, 2013 04:58 PM


What would you expect from her. No mention of Arabs living well in Israel. What Arab country invites Jews ?

Posted by: Anonymous at December 19, 2013 11:25 AM

Mandela funeral is a race of who is going to be more politically correct! Compare Mandela to Moses, to Jesus, to both? No, nobody compared him to prophet Muhammad! As Dr. Benjamin Carson said: Political Correctness suppresses free speech. Sylvia Thompson, a Black conservative, commented that white Americans continue to run scared at the sound of the term "racist". This is true for American media, politician and Americans. Oprah Winfrey, the Black billionaire, suggested that "In order to rid our society of racism, all racists must die....and that all people who criticize Barack Obama are racists". But this is not all. In articles of praise to Mandela open to comments not one out of scores of comments voiced criticism. My comment was not published, apparently rejected. But the truth today is in the Internet. In post Apartheid a million Whites left SA. Jacob Zuma SA president declared in 2009 that the Afrikaners (Dutch German who settled in SA in 17 century) are the only true tribe of white people in Africa. The rest, by inference, are outsiders. There is unemployment of 22,7%, 31,3% are below poverty line, dependency ratio of 53,9% (more than half of the population needs support), In 2005 4,2 million in SA earned less than a dollar a day twice the number (1,9 millions) in the immediate post Apartheid period. Inflation is 5,7% . 5,6 millions have HIV. The crucial time for SA was 1994-1999 when Mandela was SA president. Mandela also created an atmosphere in which terrorism. a way to settle disputes, is acceptable. More, with bishop Desmond Tutu as a moral compass he justified terrorism against Israel that in the last few years the BDS movement became purely anti Semitic. Students protesters chanting “Dubula iJuda? (Shoot the Jews) is heard in SA campus. No wonder that both Israel president Shimon Peres and PM Netanyahu stayed home. Today we must acknowledge that there is plight of Whites in SA. Those who did not leave are subjected to hardships and murder. Still SA is living on the dividend of the Apartheid years which created the infra structure of modern SA.

Posted by: Isel Brzezinski at December 19, 2013 12:18 PM

Amanpour is only carrying out CNN's decades old policy. Defame Israel at every opportunity - even the truth doesn't count for much.

Posted by: Russell Gaddin at December 19, 2013 12:26 PM

I am tired of all the slurs Amanpour is always throwing about Israel..why doesn't Cnn correct her untrue statements...her falsehood create such a wrong impression. I for one will stop watching CNN..until something is done to get her to retract her statements...

Posted by: Anonymous at December 19, 2013 12:43 PM

Could the fact that Amanpour is an Iranian have anything to do with her negative reporting on Israel?

Posted by: Bernardo at December 22, 2013 01:07 PM

Follow the money. see the advertising $ and contributions that CNN, various newsmen and politicians get fro middle eastern sources or their subsidized reps in the West and the answer is obvious

Posted by: zvi fink at December 23, 2013 08:03 AM


Posted by: ralph at December 26, 2013 11:29 AM

Guidelines for posting

This is a moderated blog. We will not post comments that include racism, bigotry, threats, or factually inaccurate material.

Post a comment

Remember Me?

(you may use HTML tags for style)