SNAPSHOTS-TOP.jpg

« NY Times Corrects: Ramat Shlomo Not a Settlement | Main | NGO Monitor: EU Promotes Arab Initiative Among Israeli Journalists »

April 18, 2010

Yemini Takes Out Blau's Assassinations Article

In his 2008 article in Ha'aretz, Israeli journalist Uri Blau used illegally obtained military documents obtained by soldier Anat Kamm to accuse the army of committing war crimes and violating a High Court ruling by assassinating West Bank terrorists. As pointed out recently in Snapshots, a letter by former Attorney General Menachem Mazuz destroyed Blau's claims that the killings violated the court ruling.

Now Ben-Dror Yemini of Ma'ariv has thoroughly decimated Blau's allegations. In "Libel Manufactured by Ha'aretz," he writes:

The headline, at the time, was "The chief-of-staff and IDF leadership authorized killings of wanted and innocent men." The expression "innocent" appears almost 20 times in the article in which the documents were published. The impression is that the IDF has been committing war crimes. This is the impression "Haaretz" intentionally attempts to create. . . .

Well, we should rise to the challenge, and examine what exactly these documents show. The main argument, which the paper attempted to promote, was that the High Court of Justice ruled that targeted killings were illegal. There is indeed a ruling, but nowhere is there any ruling that forbids targeted killings. The High Court of Justice did not go down this path, and wisely so. It was no other than Aharon Barak who made the determination in 2006: that it is impossible to determine a priori that all targeted killings are forbidden by international law, just as it is impossible to determine a priori that all targeted killings are permissible according to international law. This is very clear statement that is somewhat at odds with the impression received when reading "Haaretz" back then, when the documents appeared in Uri Blau’s article, and certainly today, as the paper attempts to hide behind the guise of exposing the truth.

It is well worth reading Yemini's entire expose.

Posted by TS at April 18, 2010 08:22 AM

Comments

There is nothing wrong with killing armed terrorists. This is justified by international law. And it is correct to kill them before they kill innocent people. No one in Israel has ever called for the assassination of innocent people. There is a difference between self-defense and murder. What is sad is the inability of Haaretz and Uri Blau to appreciate the critical difference between the two acts.

Posted by: NormanF at April 18, 2010 11:19 PM

Guidelines for posting

This is a moderated blog. We will not post comments that include racism, bigotry, threats, or factually inaccurate material.

Post a comment




Remember Me?

(you may use HTML tags for style)