« Wall Transits From MLK to David Duke | Main | The EU on Hezbollah: What are the Consequences »

July 17, 2013

Where's the Coverage? Abbas Already Spurned Everything Palestinians Demand


In an interview with The Tower published two months ago, former Israeli Prime Minister Ehud Olmert gave a detailed description of his negotiations with Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas in September of 2008:

“In the last meeting I brought a big map, like the size of this whole table,�? recalls Olmert. “With colors for all the regions that go over to us and the reverse. We would receive 6.3%, they would get 5.8%, but they also get a safe passage in a tunnel between Gaza and the West Bank that was the equivalent in territory of the remaining half percent.


“I completely gave up on having an Israeli presence in the Jordan Valley. That was because I could protect the line of the Jordan River through an international military force on the other side of the Jordan River. There was no opposition on the Palestinian side to our having a presence in warning stations along the mountain range.�? But you essentially gave up on Israeli sovereignty on the Temple Mount [the holiest site in Judaism]?

Olmert: “Correct, I proposed a compromise on sovereignty over the Temple Mount. There would be no sovereignty for anyone else. There would be the joint administration of the five states [Saudi Arabia, Jordan, Palestine, the United States, and Israel].�?

In addition, the article outlines Olmert’s proposal to take in 5,000 Palestinian refugees, 1,000 each year over five years, into Israel proper.

In other words, Olmert offered a territorial proposal based on the 1949 armistice lines –often incorrectly referred to as the 1967 borders– with “land swaps�?, contiguity between Gaza and the West Bank, no Israeli military presence in the Jordan Valley, relinquishing Israeli sovereignty over the Temple Mount, and absorption of some Palestinian refugees. This amounts to basically meeting all of the demands Abbas claims he seeks in final status negotiations. And yet, what was his response to Olmert? Olmert says, “I am still waiting for a phone call from him.�?

Given the current efforts of Secretary of State John Kerry to restart Israeli-Palestinian peace talks, you’d expect the details of this ground-breaking offer to be picked up widely by the media. However, aside from the Israeli or Jewish press and specialty Web sites, only The Washington Post even mentions Olmert’s spurned proposal.

One could argue that the Olmert offer is “old news,�? and indeed, CAMERA covered it at the time.

However, the day before The Tower published the Olmert interview, the magazine also ran an article that includes important new information. After the final meeting between Olmert and Abbas, Abbas returned to Ramallah. Then:

Once there he immediately convened his associates and redrew the map from memory. The document also included text scrawled on its margins, and on the reverse side, details documenting the rest of Olmert’s offer.

The Tower obtained the map, drawn on the official stationery of the office of the president of the Palestinian Authority.

Olmert Deal Map.jpg

The fact that this deal, with its unprecedented Israeli concessions, was rebuffed by Abbas casts doubt on whether the Palestinian Authority president will accept any peace agreement with the Jewish state. This is essential information when the U.S. Secretary of State is shuttling back and forth between Amman, Ramallah, and Jerusalem simply trying to get negotiations started.

Can Kerry be successful when Abbas has already spurned everything he claims the Palestinians want? Will the Palestinian Arabs accept the existence of Israel within any borders? And… where’s the coverage?

Posted by SC at July 17, 2013 09:47 PM


Abbas and other Fatah leaders has no real intention or motivation for creating, developing or maintaining a state. They are welfare queens who make a fortune in easy handouts from the EU, UN and USA. Why should they exert any energy to become independent and lose all this easy cash? Plus after years of Abbas's hate media calling Jews pigs and Apes and Abbas media glorifying slaughtering Jews as Palmediawatch has documented, only an Oslo leftist could think peace is possible with these psychos.

Posted by: Ken Kelso at July 19, 2013 10:21 AM

Its obvious, and has been since Madrid and Oslo,
that the Pales will not compromise their demands for a state at the 49 borders and E. Jerusalem.
(also 5,000 properties in W. Jerusalem).
The right of return for 4m so called refugees
is included, effectively killing the Jewish state. (there goes the neighborhood big time).
Everything else is sophistry. The real goal is to eliminate Israel replaced by a widening Muslim
caliphate. Israel acts like the loser of 3 wars
had it lost even Michael Oren.
Bibi is smart and tough, but believes in moderation..he thinks like Obama w/o 310m people
and 2m in his army. There is no compromise
with people who want you to disappear. and this
is the, Muslim goal. Bibi is hoping for a miracle..from the Divine..wont happen.
Auschwitz was closed after the Russians defeated
the German army and liberated the camp..or it would have killed all of Europes Jewry.
Get it.

Posted by: Noah Lev at July 19, 2013 11:52 AM

By the Western media ( I wont mention Arab Muslim
papers and other PR), terrorists are referred to as militants at the worse freedom fighters at best. How does this translate in geopolitical reality? Is Hezboolah a terrorist group or a humanitarian as defined in the EU jargon? Neither it seems, as only the military wing is being debated for non acceptance. Thats olike saying the KKK has a god side and a bad side ( not to be accepted as legitimate). Hitlers "My Struggle" also had chapters devoted to bettering his German people...he built roads, got the nation employed,
instilled old German history and its leaders into the future Reich to simulate. He also advocated murdering 19m Jews, all the gypies and other
unwanted peoples. He almost succeeded if not for the Allies and Russian land and soldiers.
The ultimate goal of the Pales-Arab world-Islamic a Muslim state where there is now Israel. The talks will produce the same rhetoric weve heard since Oslo 1 and 2..demonizing Israel
and allowing Iran, etc. to keep on building their
WMD...changing the conflict forever.

Posted by: Noah Lev at July 25, 2013 09:44 PM

Guidelines for posting

This is a moderated blog. We will not post comments that include racism, bigotry, threats, or factually inaccurate material.

Post a comment

Remember Me?

(you may use HTML tags for style)